Actor • Storyteller • SAG-AFTRA Member

How I Fell Into Acting

A detour to Hawai'i, an acting workshop, and one unexpected audition

I never really set out with a master plan to become an actor. Like several of the best turns in my life, I more or less stumbled into it.

The story

From Film Dreams to Hawai'i

From the episode

Magnum, P.I. — “One More Summer”

A self-playing sequence of stills from the show. Each image remains on screen for one second, and the slideshow automatically begins again when it reaches the end.

A brief visual look back at my Magnum, P.I. chapter.

I just sort of fell into acting.

I had done some acting in high school, and in the late 1970s I took classes and performed in several shows. But before my move to Hawai'i, acting was still a secondary interest.

Back then, movies like Star Wars, Jaws, and Close Encounters of the Third Kind had made me fascinated with filmmaking. I wanted to be a George Lucas or Steven Spielberg kind of person — someone who could not only imagine a new and different world, but actually create one.

In the late 1970s, I was accepted to Columbia College Hollywood in Los Angeles, a school focused on film and television. I thought that might be the road I would take.

Columbia College Main Site Semester in LA
A man in a dark suit seated outdoors in Hawai'i with Diamond Head in the background

But there was something else that had been in my mind since I was young: Hawai'i. I loved the islands long before I ever set foot there. I watched Hawaii Five-O, and I remember the Aloha Parade broadcasts around Thanksgiving, often with Jack Lord. Hawai'i had always felt like somewhere I wanted to be.

A friend of mine, Sean, was also interested in movies and Los Angeles, so we decided to make the move together. Then, at the last minute, I had a long conversation with my mother. She asked me a simple question: What would you really like to do? The answer came out before I could overthink it: live in Hawai'i.

At the time, six years of school felt like an eternity. So Sean and I flew to Los Angeles — and the next morning, I got on another plane and headed for Hawai'i. Poor Sean! He did fine, by the way. He got some parts in television and movies and still lives in California today.

A story behind the story The Rainbow Connection The fuller story of the dream that began on a freezing Cape Cod night and eventually carried me to Hawai'i, an acting workshop, and an unexpected opportunity on Magnum, P.I.

Starting Over in Hawai'i

I arrived in Hawai'i with no place to live, no job, and very little idea of what I was doing. But anyone who knows my Radio Shack and computer stories will understand what happened next: I found the local Radio Shacks and started working there.

Radio Shack storefront in Honolulu, Hawai'i

Eventually I found a place to live, had a job, found some great roommates, had some fun, and ran into a few major challenges along the way. There are several stories inside that one story.

The Bus Ride That Changed Everything

Colorful illustrated Honolulu bus stop surrounded by tropical flowers, with a small community bulletin board advertising an actors workshop

One day I was riding the bus — I didn't own a car in Hawai'i — when I saw a sign for the Honolulu Film Actors Workshop. The names on it were Jack Hogan and Dick Kindelon. Dick had worked in casting on Hawaii Five-O. I was barely getting by financially, but seeing that sign felt almost like a message from above. There were weeks when I ate rice and beans just so I could afford the classes.

The workshop was wonderful. It was a room full of people who were struggling, learning, practicing, and trying to break into the business — just like the acting-class scenes you see in movies. Jack and Dick were generous teachers, and I learned a great deal from them.

Then came one of those lucky turns that can change the direction of a life. Jack became involved with casting on Magnum, P.I. Because the series was always looking for local and new talent, a number of people from the workshop began getting opportunities to audition. Some later went on to become well known in the business. And that is how I got my chance.

My Magnum, P.I. Audition

I walked into an audition at the Diamond Head studio and found a room full of beautiful, confident-looking people — all of whom seemed more experienced than I was, and some of whom were perfectly happy to let you know it.

Entrance gate to the State of Hawai'i Hawai'i Film Studio at Diamond Head
A studio building on the Hawai'i Film Studio grounds near Diamond Head

When my turn came, I went in and read a few lines from the script in front of Donald P. Bellisario. The whole thing probably lasted five minutes. Then I walked out, went home, and felt sure I had blown my one big chance.

About two hours later, the phone rang. It was Jack Hogan: “Jerry, you got the part. Come by the studio Monday so we can fit you for costumes — and so we can copy your look for the stuntman.”

I was not prepared for any of it. The character was supposed to be a fairly young guy with blond hair. I had brown hair, a bit of a beard, and suddenly I was being fitted for a television role and a stunt double. The episode was “One More Summer”, and I played Walt Chambers.

I had one more audition for Magnum, P.I. after that, for another episode involving a visitor to Hawai'i and a pedicab ride. They ultimately cast someone more local.

An Injury, a Return to Cape Cod, and a New Direction

Not long afterward, I was playing football in a park and badly injured my knee. I spent roughly a year and a half dealing with crutches and braces, and for that period of my life, it pretty much brought my acting momentum to a stop. Eventually, the injury helped bring me back to Cape Cod.

Three people overlooking a Hawaiian bay, with the center person using crutches and wearing a knee brace

I still made trips to Boston from time to time and did some movie extra work. I worked on Tough Guys Don't Dance — where I remember seeing Farrah Fawcett while Ryan O'Neal was working on the film — and later on The Good Mother. Years later I discovered that two other young extras working on that movie were Matt Damon and Ben Affleck. I think they went on to do a couple of things after that. LOL.

Jerry Schmeer acting headshot from the 1980s

The practical problem was that acting in Boston meant taking a day off from work for an audition, then possibly another day off for a callback, plus the long drive back and forth from Cape Cod. It became difficult to keep doing that while also building a normal working life.

So in the mid-1980s, I created the Television and Film Actors Workshop of Cape Cod. It wasn't really about teaching people — adults or kids — how to act. My goal was to give actors a place where we could meet, practice, learn from one another, and keep our craft alive.

And Today...

Today I am not doing much acting, but I am still a member of SAG-AFTRA, after roughly 45 years in the Screen Actors Guild. I still take part in awards voting, and one year I had the opportunity to serve on a nominating committee.

Acting never really disappeared from my life. It simply became one part of a much larger story. And when I retire, I can easily imagine myself becoming a little more involved again. After all, the first time around, I didn't exactly plan it either. I just sort of fell into acting.

Acting has been one chapter in a much larger creative life — but it is a chapter I have never really closed.

Return to JerrySchmeer.com